Upper Perkiomen board approves 2024–25 comprehensive plan after debate over SEL 'Second Step' materials

Mar 28, 2025

The Upper Perkiomen School District board approved its 2024–25 comprehensive plan on March 27 after several directors raised concerns about Social Emotional Learning materials, including videos from the Second Step program; Superintendent Dr. Farina said parents may inspect curriculum and request exemptions under policy.

The full story

The Upper Perkiomen School District board voted to approve the district's 2024'25 comprehensive plan on March 27 after a prolonged discussion focused on Social Emotional Learning (SEL) materials and questions about videos associated with the Second Step program.

Board member (speaker 10) moved to approve the plan; the motion was seconded and carried by voice vote. Several directors urged caution before adoption while others said the materials and processes were already available for review.

Why it matters: The comprehensive plan sets curriculum priorities and compliance steps the district must file with the Pennsylvania Department of Education. Concerns from board members about SEL lessons prompted a public airing of curriculum-review procedures and parental opt-out rights.

What directors said: One board member who asked not to be identified by name in the meeting transcript (speaker 5) said she had not had time to vet all SEL materials and expressed worry that some videos could "change the attitudes, values, beliefs, worldviews, spirituality, and behavior of children" and might amount to "group counseling." She said she wanted fuller access to lesson videos before endorsing the plan.

Dr. Farina responded that Second Step had been approved by a prior board in 2017 and that the comprehensive plan itself references SEL competencies rather than the proprietary program by name. "We would never deny a parent their ability to inspect curriculum and request the exemption based on a strong religious or philosophical position," Dr. Farina said, adding that administrators will provide access to the videos and lesson materials on request.

Board member Trina (speaker 4) said she had reviewed what was posted and asked for additional documentation and justifications for items in the five-year plan; she said she was "not comfortable" approving without having seen more of the materials but acknowledged the plan contains many items she liked.

Procedural context: Solicitor Bethany (speaker 12) and Dr. Farina described the district's curriculum-inspection and exemption process. Speakers noted that parents may request to inspect units, that lesson plans are posted for review, and that parents may pursue exemptions under existing board policy. Dr. Farina said middle-school staff are compiling a list of videos that have been shown or are optional so board members and families can review them.

Public comment and follow-up: During public comment, Genevieve Luz, who identified herself as from Upper Hanover Township, defended educators' efforts to teach cultures and emotions and argued trauma-informed approaches provide resilience tools rather than "introducing trauma." The meeting record shows the board adopted the comprehensive plan that evening; the transcript does not record a numerical roll-call tally.

Next steps: The district will file the comprehensive plan with the state by the March 31 deadline, make curriculum units and lesson materials available for inspection as described by Dr. Farina, and continue stakeholder outreach. The board did not announce any immediate changes to Second Step implementation during the meeting.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓