Stakeholders split over proposed updates to Washington’s model public‑records rules

Nov 6, 2025

At an AGO Nov. 6 public hearing on proposed amendments to the model Public Records Act rules (WAC 44‑14, CR‑102 WSR 25‑20‑108), representatives of transit agencies, city clerks, law‑enforcement records officers and newsrooms clashed over triage, indexing, third‑party notice and timeline language; written comments are due Nov. 17.

The full story

The Washington State Attorney General’s Office convened a public hearing on Nov. 6 to collect oral and written comment on proposed amendments to the model Public Records Act rules in WAC 44‑14 (CR‑102, WSR 25‑20‑108). Deputy Attorney General Christina Busch opened the session, explained the process for in‑room and Zoom testimony and said written comments would be accepted until close of business on Nov. 17 at [email protected].

Supporters and critics framed the debate around a handful of core changes the Attorney General’s Office proposed: whether to require or narrow indexing by agencies, whether agencies should triage requests into “simple” and “complex” tracks, how and when third‑party notice must be given, and whether the rules should include tighter timing language such as “time is of the essence” or one‑day response expectations. Speakers also raised technology and staffing implications, including how teams, Slack, Discord and other platforms should be searched and whether automatic deletion practices must end.

Opponents from municipal and special‑purpose governments warned the changes would create unfunded mandates and litigation risk. Justin Layton, executive director of the Washington State Transit Association, said the draft “goes well beyond technical updates” and would impose operational and financial burdens on smaller agencies; he urged the AGO to define or remove vague words such as “prompt” and “diligent” and recommended extending third‑party notice timelines. Several city clerks, including Sean Campbell (Auburn) and Cassidy Miller (Washington Municipal Clerks Association), argued triage and indexing requirements would be impractical and could force staff to make subjective judgments about requesters’ priorities.

Local government groups emphasized capacity constraints. Rebecca Hendricks, chair of the Legislative Committee for the Washington State Law Enforcement Information and Records Association, urged the AGO to account for the workload of criminal justice agencies, noting that producing records can require coordination across departments and legal reviews. Paul White, a certified municipal clerk and deputy city clerk in Lacey, said the draft’s triage language conflicts with RCW 42.56.080(2), which limits discrimination among requesters.

Advocates for tighter rules and newsroom access urged clearer standards to reduce delay. Michelle Flores, executive editor of The Seattle Times, recounted examples where records sought for reporting were delayed months or years and said updated model rules could reduce protracted litigation that often follows delayed disclosures. The League of Women Voters’ representatives backed several changes—such as triage into proportional tracks and a five‑day response for single, identifiable records—arguing those steps would improve timely access.

Other participants called for stronger preservation and search requirements. Multiple commenters, including Arthur West and Joe Kunstler, urged ending auto‑delete policies and requiring agencies to maintain inventories of communication platforms and to search beyond email for responsive records. Several speakers pressed the AGO to make clear that model rules are advisory and not a substitute for legislative action; Joe Bennett, general counsel for several public agencies, said the rules should remain a resource and asked the office to avoid imposing accelerated timelines.

A few speakers raised concerns about the Attorney General’s Office’s role. Robert Scales suggested the AGO has an enforcement and representation conflict because it represents agencies in PRA litigation and also issues guidance; he proposed creating an independent pre‑litigation review body to reduce litigation costs. Several anonymous commenters and others reiterated protections for anonymity in requesters, urging that model rules not undermine statutory guarantees.

Busch closed the hearing by thanking participants, confirming the transcript and written comments will be posted on the AGO website, and saying the office will review comments thematically to decide whether to revise the proposed rules. The hearing record and any thematic responses will be posted to the AGO’s rulemaking webpage.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓