Town counsel outlines major Chapter 40A changes including new "practical difficulty" variance test
Sep 9, 2026
Clifford & Kenny attorneys briefed the ZBA on House Bill 5555, which allows electronic zoning notices, extends variance and zoning-freeze timelines, and replaces the "substantial hardship" variance standard with a more flexible "practical difficulty" balancing test that highlights housing production as a public-interest factor.
The full story
Town counsel from Clifford & Kenny LLP briefed the Canton Zoning Board on recent amendments to Mass. Gen. Laws Chapter 40A enacted as part of the FY2027 budget (House Bill 5555, signed July 9). The attorneys explained that municipalities may now use electronic notice for zoning hearings if an email address is available and that nonconforming-structure protections have been expanded, including an extension of the zoning-freeze from 12 to 24 months and lengthening the abandonment period.
Counsel described the most consequential change as a rewrite of the variance standard: the previous "substantial hardship" test has been replaced by a "practical difficulty" standard that asks the ZBA to balance benefits to the applicant and public interest (including housing production) against detriments to public health, safety and neighborhood welfare. Chris Kenny (speaking) said the new standard "replaces the old substantial hardship test with this, more flexible, practical difficulty standard," and board members probed how the change might affect conversions of commercial buildings to residential uses and the duration/appeal rules for variances. Counsel and members noted the law took effect upon the governor's signing and will likely generate new case law as courts interpret the standard.
Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓
