Eagle Point staff to default to permit‑by‑permit floodplain review while FEMA finalizes NFIP‑ESA rules

Nov 12, 2024

Community Development Director Mike Upston told the council that FEMA requires a local interim choice by Dec. 1, 2024, on compliance pathways for NFIP changes tied to the Endangered Species Act; Eagle Point staff will default to a permit‑by‑permit approach until final FEMA regulations are issued.

The full story

Community Development Director Mike Upston briefed the Eagle Point City Council on FEMA's forthcoming changes to the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) intended to ensure compliance with the Endangered Species Act, and outlined short‑term compliance options the city must choose between by Dec. 1, 2024.

Upston explained FEMA is developing an Oregon NFIP‑ESA Implementation Plan and accompanying environmental review; final implementation is expected in 2027, but until then FEMA requires communities to adopt a Pre‑Implementation Compliance Measure (PICM) as an interim step. The three PICM options are: adopt a model ordinance (when available), use a permit‑by‑permit review for proposed development in Special Flood Hazard Areas, or prohibit new development in the floodplain.

Mr. Upston told the council that, absent direction to the contrary, city staff will default to the permit‑by‑permit approach. He described some tradeoffs: permit‑by‑permit reviews can incur wetlands assessment costs and added permit processing costs, while a no‑development approach would be blanket and potentially disruptive. Councilors asked about potential impacts to insurance rates, flood‑zone designations, costs of wetlands assessments, and noncompliance risks; Upston said he will monitor FEMA progress and report back.

Why it matters: FEMA’s NFIP‑ESA integration intends to reduce harm to listed fish species and comply with the Endangered Species Act, and local PICM choices will shape how Eagle Point reviews floodplain projects in the near term. The city’s decision to use permit‑by‑permit review preserves the ability to evaluate projects individually rather than imposing a blanket moratorium.

Next steps: Upston said staff will keep the council informed and return with any recommended ordinance language or permit procedures as FEMA issues guidance and the Implementation Plan is finalized.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓