Commissioners continue deliberations on Willett LLC plan amendment after split votes; staff to draft condition language
Oct 21, 2026
The board debated whether a 20‑acre Willett LLC parcel near Sisters qualifies as agricultural land and how Goal 5 and Goal 14 standards apply; hearings officer recommended approval with conditions, commissioners split on soils/agriculture questions and instructed staff to draft written condition options (including a 10‑acre minimum) and return for further deliberation.
The full story
Caroline House, senior planner, guided the board through a deliberation matrix on a Willett LLC request to change 20 acres from Exclusive Farm Use (EFU) to Multiple Use Agriculture (MUA‑10) near Sisters. Staff identified five legal issues: whether the parcel qualifies as agricultural land under state OAR/ORS rules, whether it is part of a farm unit, Goal 5 scenic corridor protections, and Goal 14 urbanization/density concerns.
The applicant relied on a soil study showing predominately Class 7–8 soils and argued the land is not suitable for farm use; Central Oregon LandWatch countered with historical evidence and argued the parcel can function in conjunction with nearby farmland. The hearings officer had found that the applicant met its burden on soils in his recommendation; during deliberations commissioners expressed differing views — some accepted the hearings officer's conclusion, others worried that approving rezones from EFU erodes affordable farmland and harms future farmers.
A central procedural and legal question was how to treat Goal 14/LUBA precedent about lot‑size and rural density. The applicant offered a conditions agreement limiting future subdivisions to a minimum lot size of 10 acres while the property remains outside the urban growth boundary; some commissioners said that served as an effective way to avoid the Curry County/LUBA conflict while others wanted the board's verbal hearing‑stage commitments reduced to formal written conditions.
Given the split and nuanced concerns, legal staff and planning asked permission to review the hearing video and return with one or two drafted versions of the condition (the applicant‑proposed 10‑acre minimum and a stricter variant that would limit development until UGB expansion). The board agreed to continue deliberations; no final adoption occurred at this meeting.
Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓
