Bench examines how 'unreasonable obstruction' clauses work with numeric height and setback limits

Nov 6, 2026

During argument judges pressed both sides on whether 'unreasonable obstruction' is a separate judicial standard or must yield to explicit numeric covenants; counsel debated the meaning of 'view' vs 'views' and the undefined 'one-and-a-half-story' phrase.

The full story

Judges on the panel spent significant time testing whether a covenant's general prohibition on "unreasonable" obstruction of views should be read as subordinate to — or independent from — specific height, setback and size restrictions. Respondent counsel urged the court to interpret the covenants as an integrated package, saying courts must weigh orientation and placement when assessing obstruction: "If a building or a shed or a tree unreasonably obstructs the view from a dwelling, It's in violation," counsel said.

Appellants countered that reading the general clause to override specific numeric limits would render the specific covenants toothless; Aaron Orheim emphasized that prior decisions (Reese, Mack and related authority) treated the presence of specific, objective restrictions as controlling. The bench also queried whether the covenant's use of the singular word "view" — as opposed to "views" — meaningfully narrows protection and whether the trial record contains a sufficiently precise definition of a "one-and-a-half story." The parties disagreed about whether the record establishes that the only place a home could be sited on the lot would necessarily affect the neighbor's northwest view.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓