Alameda public comment splits over surf‑park plan as residents call for RFP and transparency

Nov 5, 2026

Sixteen speakers addressed the council workshop; opponents warned a developer‑funded master plan gives the appearance of a done deal and urged an open RFP, while supporters said a surf park would expand access, jobs and youth programming.

The full story

Sixteen members of the public had two minutes each to address the council during a workshop on an exclusive negotiating agreement (ENA) for a proposed surf park at Enterprise Park. Speakers reflected a sharp split between concerns about process and enthusiastic support for new recreation and community programming.

Opponents said the developer‑led outreach and the prospect of a private entity funding a master plan created an appearance of impropriety and undercut transparency. "Exclusive agreements bypasses standard municipal safeguards and shuts the public out of saying what else is possible," said resident Sylvia Conn, who urged the council to pause the ENA and require a competitive request for proposals. Several speakers raised environmental, wildlife and campground preservation concerns and pushed for a city‑led planning effort before any exclusive arrangement.

Supporters — including nonprofit leaders, local small‑business owners and longtime residents — praised the project’s potential to expand coastal access and to provide youth programs and jobs. Adriana Guerrero, executive director of Salted Roots, said a local wave pool would provide year‑round access and water‑safety training to communities who now travel hours to surf. Rachel Campos de Avenoff, who said she has walked Enterprise Park “a thousand times,” argued that a master plan could revitalize underused park infrastructure.

The council’s subsequent motion attempted to balance these views by requiring the ENA to be conditioned on a city‑led master plan that includes alternatives and public engagement. That motion passed 4–1. The decision does not approve a project; it authorizes a negotiated, time‑limited period for feasibility work and public planning.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓