Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Labor Relations topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission resolves impasse in Broward Sheriff's Office detention bargaining after narrowing management authority
Summary
After a multi‑hour public hearing and presentations by union and sheriff representatives, the county commission accepted a compromise giving limited authority to move detention staff for specified operational emergencies, with protections against punitive use.
The Broward County Commission on Tuesday resolved a bargaining impasse between the Broward Sheriff’s Office and the Federation of Public Employees (FPE) over how detention posts and facilities are assigned, approving a narrowly drawn management right to reassign staff in emergencies and other specified operational situations.
The board convened a required impasse public hearing under section 447.403 of the Florida Statutes. The hearing included testimony from union leaders, long‑service detention employees and outside corrections experts invited by the sheriff. Union leaders said longstanding seniority‑based bidding for posts and facilities (Article 21.4 of the collective bargaining agreement) keeps units stable, improves deputy familiarity with housing units and contributes to safety. Sheriff’s representatives and national corrections experts countered that modern jail management requires greater managerial flexibility to respond to medical emergencies, assaults, deaths in custody and other operational exigencies.
After extended testimony the parties presented compromise language and asked the commission to resolve the impasse. The board adopted the compromise language unanimously.
Outcome: The commission approved the following operative language: "In the event of excessive sick calls, medical emergencies, assault/fights, deaths in custody, or for other legitimate operational needs, management has the right to move detention personnel from their post to address the issue. This provision shall not be used in a punitive, arbitrary, or capricious manner. Under these circumstances, the backfill restrictions shall not apply." The decision rescinds the BSO proposal to eliminate bidding entirely and keeps seniority bidding intact except in the specified circumstances.
What’s next: The commission’s resolution settles the parties’ dispute for this bargaining cycle. The sheriff’s office said the language provides needed flexibility to staff housing areas and respond to emergencies; the union said the language still preserves core seniority protections while adding limited, defined management authority. Both sides indicated they will monitor implementation and use the contract grievance process to address any disputes over misuse of the authority.
