Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Ground Floor Residential Legalization topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning Commission legalizes long-standing ground-floor residence at 2839-20 Fourth Street
Summary
The San Francisco Planning Commission unanimously approved a conditional use authorization Oct. 15 to legalize a roughly 850-square-foot ground-floor residential unit at 2839-20 Fourth Street, citing tenant retention and neighborhood context; the owner committed that rent would not increase when tenants return.
The San Francisco Planning Commission on Oct. 15 unanimously approved a conditional use authorization to legalize an approximately 850-square-foot ground-floor dwelling at 2839‑20 Fourth Street in the Mission District.
Planning Department staff, represented at the hearing by Kimberly Duranday, recommended approval after reviewing applicable Planning Code provisions and outreach the project sponsor said it had conducted with the Calle Venti Cuatro Latino Cultural District. Duranday told commissioners the department found the project to be consistent with the general plan and that while it would remove a small amount of commercial space, legalizing the unit would prevent displacement and add housing to the city’s stock. Staff also noted one letter in opposition and said the unit’s proximity to a place of entertainment triggers noise-attenuation conditions under chapter 1.16 of the Administrative Code.
Tom Tunney, speaking for the project sponsor and property owners, said the building is family‑owned — ‘‘11 descendants of the original owner’’ — and that the tenant household has occupied the unit for many years. Tunney said sprinkler upgrades would be required to legalize the unit and that the owner had committed the rent would not increase when the current tenants return. ‘‘This will be a fully commercial unit and was found by the planning department to not qualify as an unauthorized dwelling unit,’’ he said, adding that legalizing the unit would preserve neighborhood character.
Multiple callers from the Mission neighborhood and neighborhood organizations voiced support during public comment, arguing that converting the small storefront to a legal residence would keep a longtime family housed during the economic strains of the COVID‑19 pandemic. Marie Sorensen of the Calle Venti Cuatro organization and Eric Arguello, identified as council president for the Calle de Guadalupe Latino Cultural District, both urged approval and said the owner had provided a rent commitment to return the family on the same terms.
Commissioners framed the decision as a preservation measure. Commissioner Moore said the building ‘‘fosters neighborhood interaction’’ and noted that many storefronts in the area are currently vacant. Commissioner Imperial said the conversion would retain a household rather than displace it. Commissioner Diamond moved to approve the conditional use authorization as amended by staff; the motion was seconded and passed on a 6–0 roll-call vote.
The approved conditions include the noise‑attenuation measures recommended by Entertainment Commission staff and life‑safety upgrades (sprinklers) necessary to legalize the unit. The decision does not change any rent or eviction protections beyond the owner’s stated rent commitment. Any required building or fire‑safety permits must be obtained before occupancy is reestablished.
The commission’s action follows earlier procedural business at the remote hearing, including continuances and consent approvals. No appeal or additional hearing date was announced on the record for this item.
