Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Grading Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
MES presenter outlines shift to standards-based grading with letter grades for upper elementary
Summary
Ms. Daniel told the board the district will keep standards-based reporting for K'1 but add traditional letter grades for grades 3'5 alongside standards progress; the report will change the term "mastery" to "meet expectations."
Ms. Daniel presented the Middlesex elementary school's revised standards-based grading and reporting plan, tracing the shift to changes that began during the COVID disruption and describing specific revisions for the coming year.
She said standards-based reporting provides a continuum of student progress, enabling teachers, parents and students to see growth toward specific standards rather than a single, end-of-term grade. "So we change the mastery to meet expectations," Ms. Daniel said. "So at this time, in your learning, if you have an 80 to a 100%, you're meeting the expectation for that standard." She acknowledged that language such as "mastery" had caused confusion for parents who saw a student move from "M" to "P" and thought the child had regressed.
Under the revisions, K'2 will maintain a true standards-based model with streamlined reporting language to make the primary standards clearer to parents. For grades 3'5, the division will add a traditional letter grade tied to the division's existing 10-point scale while retaining standards-level progress reporting in the gradebook so parents can see both the letter grade and the underlying standard-by-standard progress.
Ms. Daniel said the PowerSchool system will accumulate standards data across the year and allow teachers to tag assignments to standards; conversion formulas will provide percentiles and labels such as "meeting expectations" and "progressing." She also said the district has added reporting for observed standards—such as citizenship, problem solving and reasoning—that do not map neatly to traditional numeric grades.
The board asked for clarification on how standards would translate to letter grades; Ms. Daniel said meeting expectations equates roughly to an 80'100% (B'A range), progressing to 60''9% (C'D range) and below 60% indicating limited understanding. The administration said it will review parent communications to reduce confusion at the transition from elementary to middle school.
