Lifetime Citizen Portal Access — AI Briefings, Alerts & Unlimited Follows
Naples council approves indoor live entertainment for Prime Social Reserve over objections, 4–3
Loading...
Summary
After testimony from the applicant and a lengthy exchange over parking, acoustics and life‑safety, council approved indoor live entertainment for Prime Social Reserve with conditions including closed doors/windows, manager‑controlled volume, routine sound checks and a fire‑alarm shunt trip; council added a New Year's Eve 1 a.m. allowance. The measure passed 4–3.
Council members approved a petition allowing indoor amplified live entertainment at Prime Social Reserve, a rooftop restaurant on 5th Avenue South, after an extended hearing that included presentations by the applicant’s attorney and architect and technical questions from council and staff.
Clay Brooker, representing the applicant, summarized the request as indoor live entertainment limited to two small alternative 3‑by‑5‑foot locations and no more than one performer at a time, with doors and windows closed during performances. "Live entertainment is located entirely indoors," planning staff confirmed; the petitioner also committed to routing performers through the restaurant's permanent speaker system and to centralized, locked volume controls accessible only to the manager on duty.
Planning staff and the petitioner proposed a package of conditions designed to limit noise and ensure life‑safety compliance: sound checks during business hours, prohibition on drums except steel drum, submission of equipment specifications to staff, a requirement that a manager be on site when music is played, and installation of a shunt trip tied to the fire alarm so that live entertainment would shut off in the event of an alarm.
Councilmembers debated whether live‑entertainment approvals on 5th Avenue South raise parking and neighborhood impact issues. Staff explained that indoor live entertainment does not change approved occupancy and that Prime Social had voluntarily allocated additional parking spaces out of the city garage for its outdoor dining when that portion was approved.
Councilmember Kramer moved approval with the nine enumerated conditions plus a requirement for the shunt trip and a New Year’s Eve allowance to 1 a.m.; Councilmember Barton seconded. The council voted 4–3 to approve the petition (Barton, Kramer, Schulz and Mayor Heitman in favor; Blankenship, Kroll and Peneman opposed). No further immediate administrative appeal was announced at the meeting.
Why it matters: The decision authorizes amplified indoor music at a prominent downtown rooftop venue while attaching conditions meant to limit sound transmission into surrounding areas. The close 4–3 vote reflects remaining council concern about neighborhood impacts and precedent for rooftop/5th Avenue live entertainment.
What’s next: Staff will require equipment specifications and the shunt‑trip installation prior to operation; the council will review live‑entertainment permits again in approximately six months and retains authority to revoke or modify approvals.
