Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Audit topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Audit of draft articles vs. transcript and style rules
Summary
Checklist audit identifying issues in the draft articles with recommended fixes (spelling, clarity, chronology, missing sourcing).
Get email alerts on the Audit topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
This audit reviews the draft articles against the Issues Rules: spelling, clarity, chronology, framing, misinformation, misidentification, out‑of‑context use, quantitative precision, process clarity, context clarity, agency clarity, question emphasis, omission, bias, and duplication. Each category lists identified issues (if any) with severity and recommended corrections.
spelling: [ {"type":"transcript_typo","description":"The transcript header spells the jurisdiction as 'WANINGTON' and contains other garbled header text (e.g., 'DEPARTMENTO IN').","severity":"medium"}, {"type":"name_inconsistency","description":"Transcript alternates between 'Altmuro' and 'Altamuro' for the Director of Public Works. The article uses 'Frank Altamuro' consistently; verify official spelling.","severity":"low"}, {"type":"name_verification","description":"Township Clerk appears as 'Juistine Christine Ciallella' in the transcript; confirm correct spelling before final publication.","severity":"low"} ]
clarity: []
chronology: []
framing: []
misinformation: [ {"type":"unsupported_statistic","description":"Council President's remark that 'vehicle theft is on the rise' is presented as a safety advisory in the article but the transcript provides no supporting data; mark as an advisory and flag as unsubstantiated in the article.","severity":"medium"} ]
misidentification: []
out_of_context: []
Quantitative precision: [ {"type":"missing_amounts","description":"Consent agenda resolutions reference grants and contracts but the transcript does not provide dollar amounts for most items; articles should state 'amount not specified' where needed.","severity":"medium"} ]
Process clarity: []
Context clarity: [ {"type":"agency_clarification","description":"ESCNJ is referenced for the playground award; article should expand the acronym on first reference (Educational Services Commission of New Jersey) if verified. If not verified in transcript, retain acronym but note 'through the ESCNJ cooperative' as quoted in transcript.","severity":"low"} ]
Question emphasis: []
omission: [ {"type":"missing_exec_session_outcome","description":"Transcript records an executive session on affordable housing litigation and notes that 'action may be taken' but does not record any outcome; articles should not imply any decision was made and must state 'no action recorded in the transcript' if relevant.","severity":"high"} ]
bias: []
duplicate: []
Attribution Lock: []
Recommendations summary: Correct the jurisdiction header to 'Washington Township' in articles, keep consistent verified spellings for named individuals where possible, mark the vehicle-theft remark as unsubstantiated advice, state 'amount not specified' for resolutions where the transcript lacks figures, and explicitly note that the executive session outcome (if any) was not recorded in the transcript.
