Commission sends contested short‑term rental permit back to planning after split vote

Jul 30, 2026

The Unified Government commissioners failed to approve a special‑use permit for a non‑owner occupied short‑term rental at 1710 N. 90th Street and voted 6–3 to return the application to planning and zoning for further review. Commissioners cited past neighborhood complaints and asked staff to tighten enforcement and condition language.

The full story

The Unified Government Board of Commissioners sent a special‑use permit application for a non‑owner occupied short‑term rental at 1710 North 90th Street back to planning and zoning after divided votes on July 30.

John Badgley, the applicant, told the commission the property operated as a short‑term rental during the World Cup period with about "18 to 20" bookings and said it has received positive ratings. "As I've become a father, as I've been married, as I've been a homeowner... I've matured," Badgley said, asking the commission to "extend grace" and noting safeguards including on‑site cameras and local contacts.

Several commissioners pushed for clearer enforcement language and for conditions tied to police reports. Commissioner Melissa Bynum said she wanted "more analysis of the conditions" and flagged that a neighbor emailed the commission after staff did not initially see the message. Planning staff told the commission there were no police reports on file from the World Cup rental period; neighbors raised complaints at the planning commission meeting that prompted review.

Commissioner Carlos Pacheco moved to approve the permit; the motion failed on a 4–5 roll call. Commissioner Bynum then moved to remand the case to planning and zoning for further analysis of property‑specific conditions; that motion passed 6–3. The mayor instructed the applicant to work with staff on potential added conditions before the item returns to the planning commission.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓