Land-use attorney warns 'CIMA' changes reduce local discretion over mining, supporting moratorium

Aug 21, 2026

A land-use attorney told the Daniel council that recent Utah legislative changes within LUDMA (referred to as 'CIMA' in the meeting) limit municipalities' discretion to constrain critical-material mining, making a moratorium a prudent step while the town completes planning work.

The full story

Nate Mitchell, a land-use attorney, told the council that changes adopted by the Utah Legislature in 2025 and 2026 — referred to in the meeting as "CIMA" — restrict the legislative discretion of local bodies to limit mining of critical materials like sand and gravel once an operation is established. He said the statute allows enlargements or changes to operations unless the local body finds the expansion would endanger public health, safety or welfare.

"What CIMA does is it takes away the legislative discretion of bodies like this one when they want to constrain the mining of critical infrastructure materials like sand, gravel, rock," Mitchell said, and recommended the moratorium to allow time for the town to consider whether and how to regulate such operations under the new state framework.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓