Madison County Board of Elections Meeting Minutes -Monthly Meeting October 15, 2025
The Madison County Board of Elections on Oct. 15, 2025, approved by split vote a plan to open a single early voting site for the March 2026 primary and a separate split vote to keep all early voting dates open except Sundays; the board directed staff to submit majority and minority plans to the State Board of Elections.
Discussion Points
•Whether to have one or multiple early voting sites for March 2026; travel conditions and voter access concerns raised by party vice chairs and public commenters.
•Whether to open Saturdays during early voting; members asked for a majority plan with specified daily hours.
Decisions
•Approved one early voting site (3–2).
•Approved opening all early voting dates except Sundays (3–2).
Directions
•Staff to draft and submit both majority and minority early voting plans to the State Board of Elections.
•Staff to include daily hours in the majority plan.
Madison County Board of Elections Meeting Minutes -Monthly Meeting September 17, 2025
The Madison County Board of Elections met Sept. 17, 2025, in Marshall and unanimously approved municipal poll worker appointments and a purchase proposal to procure PrintElect ExpressVote printers (not to exceed $9,030). The board heard a vendor demonstration, discussed printer distribution and voter privacy concerns, and adjourned at 3:37 p.m.
Discussion Points
•Board members discussed how to distribute printers to polling sites and the possibility of purchasing more units to create a uniform system.
•Democratic Party Chair Paula Dempsey raised voter privacy concerns about equipment positioning and assistance procedures.
•PrintElect demonstrated the ExpressVote printer’s technical operation and storage behavior (no wireless, files deleted on device; L&A and reconciliation files stored in software).
Decisions
•Approve meeting agenda and prior minutes.
•Approve municipal poll worker appointment list.
•Approve purchase of ExpressVote printers (≤ $9,030).
Directions
•Distribute poll worker appointments as approved.
•Procure printers up to $9,030 and schedule vendor installation and staff training (assigned to Board of Elections staff).
Madison County Board of Elections Meeting Minutes -Monthly Meeting July 22, 2025
Madison County Board of Elections held its July 22, 2025, meeting where members were sworn in, Brian Ball was elected secretary, the director reported on petition activity and a voter-repair project, and the board approved multiple polling-place relocations and voter transfers ahead of upcoming municipal elections.
Discussion Points
•Approval of agenda and prior minutes; election of Brian Ball as Secretary.
•Board discussed site availability and recent storm-related closure of a South Marshall location.
•Judge James Baker administered the oath of office to board members.
•Numbered memos reissued on UOCAVA and Same Day Registration; relevance for 2026 midterms.
•Status of Voter Repair Project (161 on list; 78 reviewed; six cured).
Decisions
•Approval of agenda and minutes, election of Secretary, and adjournment.
•No formal action on HB 958; informational only.
•Series of polling‑place relocations and voter transfers approved unanimously (5-0).
Directions
•Board to distribute minutes and record Secretary appointment.
•Director to update precinct assignments and notify affected voters under state procedures.
•State Board memos to be distributed to Board members as received.
The Madison County Board of Elections met April 16, 2025, approved routine business, reviewed budget and equipment plans, heard updates on ongoing litigation affecting ballots, and the director recommended postponing a proposed precinct consolidation until after the 2026 elections to allow public input.
Discussion Points
•Director ordered laptops; removing travel and training line items from proposed budget; two challenged voters may need ballot extraction; recommended pausing precinct consolidation until after 2026 elections
Decisions
•Agenda approved; March 19 minutes approved; meeting adjourned; no formal vote taken on precinct consolidation — recommendation to delay was recorded
Directions
•Staff to request travel/training funds as needed rather than include in base 2025–2026 budget; board to await State Board guidance and court rulings before further action on challenged ballots
Madison County Board of Elections Meeting Minutes -Monthly Meeting June 18, 2025
Madison County Board of Elections met June 18, 2025. The board recessed to recognize Chair Jerry Wallin for 18 years of service and received the director's report noting a precinct donation and budget updates; county commissioners approved the 2025-2026 county budget and the board's terms expire June 24 with new appointments scheduled June 25.
Discussion Points
•Director reported precinct donation and budget status, including missing ES&S invoice and summer conference expenses paid.
•Recognition of Chair Jerry Wallin for 18 years of service; attendees praised leadership and fairness.
•Secretary Smathers reported county commissioners\u0019 approval of the 2025-2026 county budget and provided dates for appointments and swearing-in.
Decisions
•Agenda and prior minutes approved; the meeting recessed and reconvened for recognition; meeting adjourned at 4:15 p.m.
Directions
•None: no follow-up tasks or assignments documented in transcript beyond signing a letter of appreciation and upcoming appointments.
At its May 23, 2025 meeting in Marshall, the Madison County Board of Elections unanimously approved the Reeves Home Place Farm, LLC as the Sandy Mush precinct polling site, voted to continue the Laurel Community Center lease, reviewed the director's budget report and discussed swearing-in timing under Senate Bill 382. The board adjourned at 4:01 p.m.; the next meeting is scheduled for June 18, 2025.
Discussion Points
•Board discussed swearing-in timing under SB 382 and N.C. Gen. Stat. §163-30.
•Board members discussed upcoming board appointments and the swearing-in schedule after enactment of Senate Bill 382.
•Director Ray reported budget presentation to county commissioners went well and expressed confidence in FY2026 funding.
•Director Ray reported on budget presentation outcomes and noted overdrawn line items requiring transfers.
•Secretary Smathers noted countywide elimination of travel line items and new travel reimbursement processing via the county finance officer.
•Secretary Smathers reported a site visit to Reeves Home Place Farm and recommended it for Sandy Mush precinct.
Decisions
•Agenda approved (5-0).
•April 16 minutes approved (5-0).
•Laurel Community Center lease continued (5-0).
•Meeting adjourned at 4:01 p.m. (5-0).
•No formal budget adoption or vote recorded at this meeting; director to submit line-item transfer requests to correct overdrawn expense lines.
•Reeves Home Place Farm established as Sandy Mush polling site (5-0).
Directions
•Board to document and finalize logistics for Reeves Home Place Farm as a polling site (parking, ADA, signage) by next meeting.
•Director Jacob Ray will contact the state board for clarification on swearing-in timing prior to the June 18 meeting.
•Director Jacob Ray will contact the state board for clarification on swearing-in timing under General Statute §163-30 before the June 18 meeting.
At its Jan. 15, 2025, meeting in Marshall, the Madison County Board of Elections voted unanimously to ask the county attorney to review whether the elections director should be classified as exempt under the Fair Labor Standards Act and heard updates on 2025 municipal election planning, training changes and related election-law developments.
Discussion Points
•Board members referenced broader election-related context (NC Supreme Court protest) and the need for legal review.
•Introduction by director and HR director of proposed change from exempt to non-exempt status; board members raised concerns about implications for duties and pay.
•Multiple procedural approvals and one substantive referral to the county attorney for legal guidance on FLSA classification.
•Planned equipment procurement for the fiscal year; changes to Hot Springs charter; Hurricane Helene reimbursement; poll-worker training updates; monitoring of SB 382.
Decisions
•All motions recorded as approved; the attorney-review referral is pending the county attorney opinion.
•Board voted 5-0 to request a county attorney opinion; no reclassification adopted at the meeting.
•No formal action recorded on the director's report.
Directions
•Chair, secretary and director to meet with county attorney per Member Ponder's request.
•County attorney to review the Fair Labor Standards Act and provide an opinion on the director position's exemption status.
The Madison County Board of Elections met March 19, 2025, to approve routine minutes and agenda, hear a members' report on a state bill (House Bill 411) and equipment support, and consider possible precinct consolidations ahead of a June 30 filing deadline. The director reported a recommended polling location for the Town of Marshall election, recent equipment purchases and that more public input will be sought at the April meeting.
Discussion Points
•AB Tech Madison Campus identified as a potential municipal polling location
•June 30 deadline to submit precinct consolidation plans to NC State Board of Elections (Jacob Ray)
•Limited available voting sites in Sandy Mush and South Marshall areas
•Madison County equipment not affected by ES&S phase-out (Jacob Ray)
•Poll worker recruitment and budget line-item credit explanation (board and director)
•Pros and cons of consolidating North Marshall and South Marshall precincts
•Summary of House Bill 411 and potential effects on early voting hours (Dyatt Smathers)
Decisions
•Approved agenda and minutes; adjourned meeting
Directions
•No formal direction recorded to change operations; staff to include laptop purchase in next budget report and provide more information on precinct consolidation by April meeting.
•Staff to prepare technical information and public engagement materials for April meeting
Madison County Board of Elections held its regular monthly meeting on Feb. 26, 2025, approving several budget and compensation changes and authorizing procurement while reviewing operational readiness for the 2026 municipal elections.
Discussion Points
•Briefing on ExpressVote Printer with input from NC State Board technician and a poll worker.
•County Attorney supports keeping the director’s exempt status.
•Director's exemption status affirmed by County Attorney recommendation to keep exempt.
•Securing municipal election sites and potential loss of South Marshall precinct for 2026.
•South Marshall precinct likely unavailable in 2026 and board to investigate alternatives.
•Staffing and workload increases tied to absentee and provisional deadline changes.
•State legislature activity may affect elections and public comment on state rule changes is open.
Decisions
•Approve procurement of 10 laptops.
•County Attorney advised maintaining director’s exempt status (as reported by the director).
•Increase board stipend by $15/month.
•Increase director/deputy salaries by 3%.
•Increase poll worker and judge pay rates.
•Reduce ExpressVote printers request from 8 to 7.
Directions
•Board to adjust capital equipment request to seven ExpressVote Printers and incorporate approved pay increases into the FY2026 budget.
•Director authorized to proceed with procurement of 10 laptops and to reach out to FEMA regarding reimbursement.
•Director to investigate alternative polling locations for South Marshall precinct and to contact FEMA about potential reimbursements.
Madison County Board of Elections Meeting Minutes -Monthly Meeting March 19, 2025
Madison County Board of Elections met March 19, 2025, to discuss a June 30 deadline for precinct consolidation packets, potential impacts of House Bill 411 on early-voting hours, voting equipment status, and municipal election logistics; the board approved the agenda and minutes and adjourned.
Discussion Points
•Confirmation of AB Tech Madison Campus as a polling site
•June 30 deadline to submit precinct consolidation plans to NC State Board of Elections (presented by Director Jacob Ray)
•Lack of available voting sites in Sandy Mush and South Marshall precincts
•Need for more public input and technical information
•No issues in proposed 2025–26 budget
•Poll-worker recruitment strategies and municipal filing questions
•Pros and cons of consolidating North Marshall and South Marshall precincts
•Purchase of 10 new laptops to be shown in budget report
•Question about ES&S equipment support and local impact
•Summary of House Bill 411 and its potential effect on early voting hours
Decisions
•Agenda and February minutes approved; meeting adjourned at 4:01 p.m.
•No formal action taken; informational only
•No formal decision or motion on consolidation at March 19 meeting
Directions
•Director Jacob Ray to present new information at April meeting
•Director to reflect laptop purchase in next budget report
Madison County Board of Elections Meeting Minutes -Monthly Meeting January 15, 2025
Madison County Board of Elections met Jan. 15, 2025, and voted unanimously to approve agenda and prior minutes. The board discussed a proposed change to the elections director's exemption status and asked the county attorney to review the Fair Labor Standards Act; staff also reported on 2025 municipal election preparations, training updates and pending legislation.
Discussion Points
•Brandi Rice (HR) described the county's proposal to change the director's employment status from exempt to non-exempt.
•Director reported on election planning, charter changes affecting Hot Springs, Hurricane Helene reimbursement, planned equipment procurement, poll-worker training changes, and SB 382 monitoring.
•Members expressed operational and governance concerns and requested legal guidance.
Decisions
•Motion to request county attorney review passed unanimously; no personnel reclassification enacted at the meeting.
•No formal operational decisions or procurements were approved at the meeting.
Directions
•Chair, Secretary and Director to meet with county attorney to discuss the board position.
•County attorney to review the Fair Labor Standards Act and provide a written opinion on the director's exemption status.
•Staff to monitor SB 382 and Hot Springs charter changes and report back as necessary.
December 4, 2024 Special Meeting Minutes - Hand-Eye Sample Audit
Madison County Board of Elections held a special meeting on Dec. 4 to conduct a bi-partisan sample hand-to-eye audit for NC Supreme Court Associate Justice Seat 06; the board reported the sample audit matched the recount with no discrepancies and approved minutes and adjourned.
Discussion Points
•Board reviewed and signed paperwork from the bi-partisan hand-eye team.
•Director Jacob Ray reviewed Numbered Memo 2024-09 and reported sample audit matched recount results.
Decisions
•Adjourn meeting at 9:55 a.m. (4-0).
•Approve absentee minutes for Oct. 29 and Nov. 4, 2024 (4-0).
December 2, 2024 Special Meeting Minutes - Protest Hearing
Madison County Board of Elections held a special evidentiary protest hearing Dec. 2, 2024, on whether M. William Brooks Wallace was eligible to vote in the Nov. 5, 2024 general election; the board accepted exhibits, voted unanimously to let Wallace’s vote stand, and directed staff to issue a dismissal notice.
Discussion Points
•The board accepted exhibits 1–3 into the record and considered a motion regarding Wallace’s ballot.
•The proceeding was an evidentiary protest hearing concerning a voter eligibility challenge for M. William Brooks Wallace.
Decisions
•Board voted unanimously to allow M. William Brooks Wallace’s Nov. 5, 2024 vote to stand.
Directions
•Board directed the attorney and the election director to prepare and send a dismissal notice to the parties involved.
November 20, 2024 Special Meeting Minutes Re-Count
Madison County Board of Elections held a special meeting Nov. 20, 2024 to complete a recount for the North Carolina Supreme Court Associate Justice, Seat 06, and found no differences between the original results and the recount. The board advanced a protest submitted by Justice Jefferson Griffin to an evidentiary hearing scheduled for Dec. 2, 2024 at 4:00 p.m.; the director will secure a location and provide notice.
Discussion Points
•Board conducted preliminary consideration of a protest submitted by Justice Jefferson Griffin.
•Board members recessed and reconvened multiple times to complete recount procedures.
•Board reviewed and signed off on recount results and found no differences from the original count.
•Director Jacob Ray reviewed NC SBE Memo 2024-08 as recount guidance.
Decisions
•Meeting adjourned at 2:30 p.m.
•Protest advanced to evidentiary hearing scheduled for Dec. 2, 2024 at 4:00 p.m.
•Recount results signed off with no differences recorded.
Directions
•Director to secure location for evidentiary hearing and provide proper notice.
The Madison County Board of Elections met Nov. 15, 2024, to complete the canvass of the Nov. 5 general election. The board sustained two voter challenges, authorized retrieval of 15 ballots for manual review, reviewed audits and incident reports, and voted unanimously to certify the election results.
Discussion Points
•Board authorized retrieval and manual review of fifteen ballots due to failed verification and sustained challenges.
•Director presented voter-history reconciliation and incident reports; hand‑eye audit reviewed by bipartisan team.
•Two voter challenges were presented and sustained based on evidence presented by the director and Senior Election Specialist Kathy Ray.
Decisions
•Adjourn at 3:15 p.m.
•Certify the Nov. 5, 2024 General Election results (vote 5-0).
•Retrieve and manually review fifteen ballots.
•Sustain voter challenge to Ronald Shelton (felony conviction).
•Sustain voter challenge to Sadie English (residential status).
Directions
•Copies of incident reports and finalized canvass materials to be made available via public records request.
•Staff to conduct manual edits and reviews of the identified ballots under board supervision and file certified canvass documents with notarial seal.
November 14, 2024 Absentee Supplemental & Provisional Meeting Minutes
The Madison County Board of Elections met Nov. 14, 2024, to count and approve supplemental absentee and provisional ballots, approving 24 supplemental absentee ballots across precincts and resolving 147 provisional applications; the director reported two voter challenges and a potential recount scheduled for Nov. 20.
Discussion Points
•Board members praised staff and poll workers for a well-run election and quick reporting of results.
•Director Jacob Ray reported two voter challenges and indicated a potential recount scheduled for Nov. 20.
Decisions
•Approved 24 supplemental absentee ballots across nine precincts.
•Disposition of 147 provisional applications: 34 approved, 113 denied as recorded by category.
Directions
•Director to include two voter challenges in the canvass and to proceed with recount procedures if required on Nov. 20.
November 5, 2024 Election Day Absentee Meeting Minutes
At a Nov. 5, 2024 absentee session in Marshall, the Madison County Board of Elections duplicated one ballot that would not tabulate, voted unanimously to tabulate absentee mail-in ballots, recessed and later completed reconciliation, uploaded results to the state, and adjourned after an election-night canvass.
Discussion Points
•Board members agreed to proceed with tabulation of absentee mail-in ballots and to recess for processing.
•Staff reported one absentee ballot from Hot Springs Senior Meal Site would not tabulate and was duplicated so it could be counted.
Decisions
•Motion to adjourn passed 5-0 at 8:45 p.m.
•Motion to recess until 7:00 p.m. passed 5-0.
•Motion to tabulate absentee mail-in ballots passed 5-0 at 3:00 p.m.
Directions
•Recess until 7:00 p.m. to complete reconciliation and tabulation.
•Staff to reconcile early voting equipment, close chains of custody, prepare and sign abstract, and upload results to state reporting software.
The Madison County Board of Elections met November 4, 2024, approved an Election Day poll worker list, certified and approved absentee ballots for precincts, verified chain of custody for the DS200 absentee scanner, recorded an ending absentee ballot count of 436 and sealed the machine for storage.
Discussion Points
•Precinct-level logistical issues (traffic at Hot Springs; ram board installation at Sandy Mush); proposal to locate Board office in proposed judicial complex; chain-of-custody verification for DS200; duplication procedure for overseas/military ballots.
Decisions
•Agenda approved; Election Day poll-worker list approved; absentee ballot batches for 12 precincts approved; DS200 sealed for storage.
Directions
•Staff to continue logistics and installation work at precinct sites; next absentee meeting set for Nov. 14, 2024 at 3:00 p.m.
The Madison County Board of Elections met Oct. 29, 2024, in Marshall to approve an Election Day poll worker list, review director updates, and certify 297 absentee ballots from multiple precincts ahead of the election. All motions passed unanimously (5-0).
Discussion Points
•Director Jacob Ray updated Mars Hill voting enclosure and reviewed poll worker assignments.
•Early voting turnout and local polling logistics (reported by Secretary Smathers and Chair Wallin; Member Ponder raised Election Day traffic concerns).
Decisions
•Approve absentee ballot batches from 12 precincts (5-0 each).
•Approve Election Day poll worker list (5-0).
•Duplicate overseas/military ballots and scan duplicates into DS200.
Directions
•Verify chain of custody for the DS200 prior to counting and seal machine after processing.
At an Oct. 22, 2024 Madison County Board of Elections absentee meeting, the board duplicated seven early-voting ballots that failed to tabulate at Beech Glen, approved multiple absentee ballots and poll-worker appointments unanimously, and heard public comments raising privacy concerns at early voting sites.
Discussion Points
•Director's update on incident reports and privacy complaints at early‑voting sites.
•Multiple precinct absentee ballot approvals and poll‑worker appointments.
•Process and authorization to duplicate seven ballots that failed to tabulate at Beech Glen.
•Reports on early voting startup and site visits by members.