Finance, Administration, and Strategic Operations Committee 11/12/2026
The transcript covers a transportation-appeals committee, legal services and planning contracts, transit buses, and a possible fire-vehicle purchase. No formal votes or final approvals are captured in the provided excerpt.
Discussion Points
•Additional staff rates were described as ranging from $200 to $720 an hour.
•A participant argued for smaller buses and more frequent service, citing potential fuel savings.
•A participant asked whether the existing fleet would last until replacement buses arrive in 2029.
•A participant cited a $50,000 budget and $27,885.50 paid through October.
•A participant suggested consent-agenda placement; no vote is captured.
•A staff member characterized the budget as an estimate and said charges depend on work performed.
•A staff member described a 2013 fire vehicle priced at $405,000 and said it had half the mileage and hours of the current vehicle it could replace.
•A staff member described an appeal process under municipal code section 272 for taxi and livery operator matters.
•A staff member estimated annual ridership at 300,000 to 400,000 and said the Department of Transportation approves buses based on statistics.
•No purchase motion or approval is recorded.
•Participants discussed a letter of intent and returning to council for further discussion.
•The committee decides whether the challenged office decision stands or is modified.
•The described committee consists of three council members and the police chief, with both sides presenting information.
•The proposed rate was described as $355 an hour, compared with a $300 hourly cap referenced for 2026.
•The staff member proposed inspection and a parts-availability check before a purchase decision.
•The staff member said no further appeal after the committee was documented and a city attorney would attend the hearing.
•The transcript records no response to the fleet-life question and no decision on service or bus size.
•The vehicle would require equipment transfer and training; the staff member estimated about a month for preparation.
Community, Legislation, Infrastructure, and Public Safety - COW - November 10, 2026
Oneonta Common Council met Nov. 10, 2026 to continue budget work for 2027, focusing on closing a roughly $300,000 gap by considering cuts (overtime, capital projects, deferred raises) and revenue options including paid downtown parking; council gave staff a general nod to develop a paid-parking proposal for 2027.
Discussion Points
•Airport hangars and DOT grants cited as examples requiring local match if awarded.
•Concerns about equity, resident exemptions, student semester permits and potential displacement to Main Street.
•Paid parking, gate/kiosk/permit models, enforcement responsibilities and administrative costs.
•Proposal to combine HR and finance under a single director to reduce overhead.
•Reducing fire overtime (4,000 hours cited); delaying council-chambers rehab ($150,000); deferring administrator raises; vacancy budgeting; use of committed capital funds and grant-dependent projects.
•Suggestion to defer or halve administrator raises for six months as interim savings.
Oneonta Common Council heard extended public comment opposing airport work on adjacent private land, adjusted several reserve accounts, debated whether to authorize a property-tax levy above the state tax cap and continued a detailed budget discussion that included fire overtime and potential new revenue ideas.
Discussion Points
•Council discussed alternate access routes parallel to the runway vs. reopening an old access road, and liability if city equipment is used on disputed land.
•County plan identifies aging water mains (66 miles), failing bridge decks and culverts; staff encouraged alignment with capital planning.
•Hiring four additional firefighters could reduce overtime but requires training and staggered hires to avoid long‑term replacement cliffs.
•Motion to pause airport work discussed and postponed pending legal analysis.
•One councilor said closing the $411,000 gap via a 6.77% levy would average $103/year per taxpayer.
•Others said pushing the decision until after further budget discussion would allow more clarity and avoid confusing multiple votes.
•Participation helps maintain eligibility for FEMA and other mitigation grants but does not guarantee funding.
•Pilot project reduced callbacks substantially; overtime request in draft budget rose from 7,000 to 11,000 hours.
•Repairs reserve explained as statutory reserve intended for infrequent, high‑cost repairs (elevator, roof).
•Reserves proposed to capture remaining 2025 fund balance and an additional temporary one‑time revenue item; members debated appropriate allocations for parks and IT.
•Reserve transfers approved with a friendly amendment; council debated but did not finalize above‑cap levy.
•Residents reported city equipment and contractors were operating into privately owned land and raised due‑process and notice concerns.
•Warrants and consent items passed by roll/voice votes.
Decisions
•Council to participate in the county hazard mitigation plan.
•Initial motion tabled; reconsideration passed to allow above‑cap option to remain available for final budget vote.
•Motion approved with friendly amendment to increase parks to $150,000 and IT to $100,000.
•No final vote to halt work; matter postponed pending legal clarifications.
•No immediate hiring vote; staff to return with projections and the overtime amount remains in draft budget for now.
•Warrants and reserves approved; tax cap authorization tabled then reconsidered; pause motion postponed.
Directions
•City attorney and project staff to provide maps, legal memo on road status and options for alternate access.
•Council to hold follow‑up briefing before any enforcement or cessation order.
•Finance to implement transfers and reflect the amended numbers in budget materials.
•Finance to provide refined numbers and scenario analyses for Nov. 24 hearing.
•Staff to incorporate mitigation needs into 2027 capital and budget deliberations.
•Staff to prepare legal memos, budget scenarios and updated project access options for next meetings.
•Staff to present multi‑year staffing and overtime scenarios and timing implications at next budget meeting.
Committee of the Whole (Finance, Administration, and Strategic Operations) met October 29 to continue the 2027 budget review, including a detailed proposal to change water/sewer billing structure, discussion of staffing vacancies (notably police), and revenue options to close a roughly $761,000 gap.
Discussion Points
•Council debated budgeting vacancies fully vs. staggering or holding some positions unfilled to reduce 2027 expenditures.
•Council debated fully funding new officer lines in 2027 vs. staging hires or preserving lines without full-year funding.
•Neighboring water district indicated willingness to pay for a second well to secure capacity.
•Paid parking could generate revenue but requires enforcement; the city has a parking reserve available for implementation.
•Police representation described current patrol staffing and warned of cascading operational impact and insurance/liability implications if staffing declines.
•Pump house had copper theft and drug paraphernalia; fencing was installed as safety measure.
•Staff presented vacancy list and estimates for new positions including fire marshal and firefighters totaling over $765,000.
•Staff proposed implementation in January 2027 tied to reprogramming Tyler billing software and initial quarterly billing before monthly bills.
•Staff proposed three-tier water rate and base-fee model to fund capital; council debated base-fee level ($15–$25).
•Staff reported sales-tax remittance above last year for the month cited and suggested conservative upward projection options.
Directions
•Staff to include pump-house security and proposed second well in capital planning and in the rate/reserve modeling.
•Staff to model net revenue from paid parking (accounting for enforcement) and to prepare sales-tax projection scenarios for next council meeting.
•Staff to provide reserve-threshold modeling and pro forma showing impacts at $15,$17,$20,$25 base-fee levels for next meeting.
•Staff to provide scenarios showing operational impacts and budget implications of hiring 0–5 officers in 2027.
•Staff to return with refined deficit scenarios showing alternatives (sales-tax variation, reserve usage, staged hiring) for the next meeting.
The Oneonta appeals board heard multiple property appeals, granted an appeal for 343 Chestnut Street, resolved a notification dispute for 370 Main Street, and approved a fee adjustment while reviewing inspection and repair plans for several properties. The board also discussed upcoming appeals (porch furniture), administrative items and an upcoming chair election.
Discussion Points
•A summons related to accounting may be involved
•Available mitigation includes up to 50% fee reduction under code; a 90% reduction was proposed
•Code prohibits indoor furniture on unenclosed front and side porches
•Discount Liquor received $5,000 admin fee letter
•New owners (Frank and cousins) recently took responsibility after executor paperwork finalized (approx. Aug. 25)
•One appeal fully submitted; another appellant working on compliance
•Separate electrical violation reports require the same inspector to re-inspect after repairs
•Staff practice of treating reoccupied properties as rentals unless a property-use form is returned
•Timing of certificate receipt (appellant: approx. Oct. 14)
•Timing of mailed notification vs. transfer of possession
•Whether property was vacant and when it was reoccupied
•Whether the new owner received proper notice before taking possession
Decisions
•Appeal granted
•Appeal granted; staff to process documentation and inspections
•Board granted appeal and agreed to adjust fees; specific reduction to be recorded in case files
Directions
•Staff to bring pending appeals before board as needed
•Staff to confirm paperwork and proceed with scheduled inspections
•Staff to monitor business response and pursue enforcement as needed
•Staff to monitor inspections, confirm corrective action, and document final fee adjustments
•Staff to update the case file and notify relevant parties
Mayor Dan Buetterman outlined the council's schedule for adopting the 2027 budget, announced a planned modernization of the water and sewer billing system to go online in 2027, and said the council will not raise the tax levy beyond the state guidance of 2.01%. A tentative budget will be presented at a public hearing on November 24 and the final vote is scheduled for December 1.
Discussion Points
•Council agreed in principle to proceed; technical and procurement details not specified.
•Council has worked through October and November on the 2027 budget and will vote on Dec. 1.
•Modernization will align billing to individual usage and add payment options.
•Tentative budget will be available and discussed at a public hearing on Nov. 24.
•The mayor reported the council's decision but no formal vote was recorded in these segments.
•The tax levy will be held to state guidance of 2.01% as part of the 2027 budget.
Decisions
•Council decision reported to cap levy at 2.01% guidance; outcome reported but no vote recorded.
•Final vote scheduled for Dec. 1; no final outcome in this transcript.
•In-principle agreement to proceed; no formal procurement decision recorded.
Directions
•Finance Department to set rates consistent with levy decision and report back.
•Residents encouraged to review tentative budget at Nov. 24 hearing.
•Residents urged to speak with council members and provide feedback ahead of the Nov. 24 hearing and Dec. 1 vote.
•Staff to pursue implementation steps and rate-setting to align with the new system.
Zoning and Housing Board of Appeals - October 28, 2026
The zoning/planning board reviewed Hartwick College's application to replace stadium lighting at Wright Stadium with a Musco system; board approved variances and the site plan after discussion of pole placement, mounting height, light spill, game schedules and code issues.
Discussion Points
•Athletic director said the college avoids night games due to inadequate light levels under current fixtures.
•Board determined project qualifies as Type 2 action (no significant environmental impact if built as proposed).
•Board discussed navigating overlapping form-based and downtown codes and agreed the code needs targeted rewriting.
•Board sought assurances about curfew, monitoring, and pole placement relative to property lines and tree lines.
•College officials said they avoid night games due to current inadequacy of light levels; improved lighting could allow limited evening uses.
•Commissioners discussed setback and mounting-height tradeoffs; vendor argued taller poles improve aiming and reduce spill.
•Interim nominees accepted with appreciation and brief comments.
•Members preferred to delay permanent leadership changes until January or next application cycle.
•Musco described efficiency improvements: moving from ~20% on-field efficiency to ~95–98% with visors.
•Musco described scene control and conference/municipal restrictions; the device can enforce curfew defaults (e.g., 10:00 p.m.).
•Staff proposed an ordinance to require contractor/engineering review for large or complex projects.
Decisions
•Application and site plan approved; variances for setback and mounting height addressed and accepted by roll call.
•Type 2 classification approved; variances and site-plan approval granted by roll call.
Directions
•Administrative staff to update records and agenda notices.
•Staff to draft ordinance language and create guidance documents explaining which code applies in the university district.
•Staff to ensure permit and site-plan documents incorporate curfew and monitoring commitments and that final photometric files match modeling shown to the board.
•Staff to verify curfew and remote-monitoring features in permit conditions.
•Staff to verify curfew defaults and monitoring configuration as described in Musco presentation when issuing permits.
Mayor Dan Buttermen said the city faces about $1,000,000 in added costs for the 2027 budget and urged residents to contact their council members as officials consider service cuts or local revenue increases to close the gap. He noted the state's tax cap at 2.01% and said the budget must be proposed by the end of November and adopted in December.
Discussion Points
•Projected $1,000,000 in added 2027 costs due to health insurance, pensions, and salaries (presented by Mayor Dan Buttermen).
•State tax-cap guidance for the year at 2.01% noted as insufficient relative to projected cost increases.
•Two broad options presented: reduce services or increase local revenues.
City of Oneonta Committee of the Whole reviewed department budget requests, a fire-department staffing pilot and proposed apparatus purchase, reductions to the DPW capital plan, options to restructure water & sewer billing (including a possible 10% revenue increase), and council guidance to close a roughly $900,000 draft budget gap.
Discussion Points
•Apparatus pre-build can be paused; bond authorization exists but financing not yet issued.
•Council must decide whether to exceed the 2.01% cap (six votes required) or to find further cuts / vacancy-management strategies.
•DPW presented a long list of deferred capital projects and staffing requests that were reduced to meet the 2% tax cap constraint.
•Further cuts may require eliminating positions or deferring safety-related projects.
•Options include phased renovation, consultants, consolidation of services, or relocation, each with large cost implications.
•Pilot showed large observed overtime reduction in a short sample; staff caution that results are preliminary and training/time-to-effect matters.
•Radio repeater hardware and tower service estimates are substantial and beyond earlier set-aside amounts; building layout creates dispatch-area communication problems.
•Remaining draft gap ~ $900,000 after cuts; staff appropriated $1.8M of unrestricted reserves in draft.
•Three candidate rate packages will be provided: current-structure 10% revenue increase; new base-fee plus usage with similar revenue outcomes for many customers; and a larger increase aimed at rebuilding reserves.
•Transition requires software programming, December meter reads, and local-law/code amendments for sewer.
•Transit will seek grants and phase bus replacements over three years to replace older 40-foot buses with smaller models.
•Zoning requested one laptop, five tablets and a snowblower to improve in-field inspections and sidewalk maintenance capacity.
Decisions
•Council agreed to consider these modest equipment requests in revised budget numbers.
•Council asked staff to present options and examples; no rate decision made in this meeting.
•No final cuts or staffing eliminations approved at this meeting.
•No final vote on apparatus purchase; no hiring decision recorded in this meeting.
•No final vote to exceed tax cap; direction given for Thursday follow-up.
•No immediate spending authorization recorded; staff to plan next steps.
Directions
•Form a council committee to review strategic building and communications options; staff to return with consultant recommendations and cost estimates.
•Include the equipment and phased transit replacement plan in next budget recalculations.
•Staff to evaluate restricted-reserve options and return Thursday with a reduced gap and levy implications.
•Staff to prepare career-cost analysis and model ranges for overtime savings; provide recruitment and pay-comparison data by Thursday meeting.
•Staff to return Thursday with recalculated gap, options that minimize layoffs, and the levy percent needed to close remaining gap.
•Staff to return with three fully worked examples, ordinance/code language changes needed, and outreach plan before the council votes.
Public commenters pressed the Oneonta Common Council to pause an airport obstruction‑clearance project over environmental concerns; council members also heard updates on homelessness and winter warming services, discussed Good Cause Eviction legislation and an airline operator contract, and reviewed a draft 2027 budget showing a roughly $942,000 general‑fund gap.
Discussion Points
•Advocates report canvassing and petitions supporting Good Cause Eviction law.
•Council asked for a cost breakdown before formal approval.
•Council members discussed tax levy options, reserve strategy and department head briefings.
•Council requested FAA documentation on grant repayment obligations before final action.
•General fund shows $942,000 deficit in the draft 2027 budget.
•Members noted that an RFP would allow the current operator to respond and compete.
•Public commenters requested independent economic and environmental reviews before proceeding with airport obstruction‑clearance work.
•Rising food insecurity and winter housing needs were reported by providers.
•Some council members and public commenters raised conduct concerns about current operator owners.
•Staff proposed $850,000 of transfers to restricted reserves with a detailed allocation to equipment and departments.
•Staff proposed joining BCPA and moving retirees to an Excellus Medicare MAPD plan with a lower projected rate increase versus renewing the current plan.
•Staff reported operational benefits from a fixed operator (fuel sales and hangar rent increases).
•Staff said some aerial imagery and environmental work exist but that design and easement phases must define exact tree removal.
•Tenants arranged an offer from Legal Services of Central New York to brief council on legal impacts.
•Visit to a Norwich RAP/warming center showed outcomes (referrals, treatment, housing placements) and zero overdoses on site, per the committee's summary.
•Warrant approval motion passed.
Decisions
•Council accepted reserve allocation as working assumption and will formalize motion at a subsequent meeting.
•Warrants approved; BCPA/Medicare plan decision deferred.
Directions
•Committee asked staff and partners to coordinate warming station openings and consider year‑round shelter models and transit improvements.
•Staff to coordinate scheduling of a Legal Services of CNY presentation and allow council Q&A before a decision.
•Staff to prepare RFP/RFQ documents and airport performance data for council review before any contract award.
•Staff to prepare scenarios, invite department heads and return with revised options to cover remaining deficit.
•Staff to provide FAA/design materials and clarify estimated acreage and repayment obligations.
•Staff to return with a detailed cost comparison for retiree coverage and procedural implications of joining BCPA.
Finance, Administration, Strategic Operations Committee - Committee of the Whole - October 15, 2026
Oneonta Common Council met Oct. 15 to handle a Ward 2 appointment and initiate detailed discussions on the 2027 budget, including health insurance increases, water/sewer rate design, and several infrastructure items; a new council member was sworn in.
Discussion Points
•65-plus plan renewal initially above 22%; staff exploring plan design changes to mitigate increase.
•All Star Village connection lacks a contract; revenue impacts unknown.
•Councilor argued that large institutional users significantly affect plant sizing and revenue distribution.
•Council signaled concurrence and proceeded to swear in the appointee during the meeting.
•Crews found four 1,000-gallon underground fuel tanks during parking-lot reconstruction.
•Current billing structure includes up to 37,000 gallons in minimum annual bill; usage billed cumulatively on a tier table.
•DEC required pumping and removal; contractor Miller Environmental Services performed the work.
•One-time bond premium of $311,075 is included in 2027 budget but not available thereafter.
•Resolution cited city charter authority to fill vacancy until next general election.
•Staff estimated approximately $30,000 removal cost and will request a budget adjustment at a future meeting.
•Staff proposed a base fee (by service size) plus usage charge to better align infrastructure costs with users.
•Staff to meet consortium board and stop-loss vendor on Oct. 22; final rates to be provided to council.
•Staff will conduct department-by-department line-item reviews to reduce the projected gap.
•State temporary assistance funding (~$750,000) is uncertain and not guaranteed for 2027.
•Tompkins County reported rate increases above 19% as a comparable data point.
Decisions
•Appointment concurred; appointee sworn in.
Directions
•Council to review budget packet and identify items for further detail; staff to return revised gap estimates after departmental meetings.
•Inform full council before any budget vote on removal costs.
•Staff to provide detailed revenue tables separating large users (colleges, hospital) and to present formal rate-change options in 2027.
•Staff to return with final premium rates and historical data for council review.
Mayor Dan Butterman announced the common council appointed Elizabeth Bloom to the 2nd Ward after Cecilia Walsh Russo resigned to take a job in Albany and outlined the 2027 budget timeline, urging public input and noting adoption is expected in December.
Discussion Points
•2027 budget will be developed through remainder of 2026
•Adoption expected in early December
•Announcement of appointment and resignation
•No procedural details or vote tallies recorded
•October designated a busy month for budget work
•Public encouraged to attend meetings or contact council members
Decisions
•Appointment announced; outcome described as appointment (no recorded vote details)
•Budget adoption planned for early December (date unspecified)
Directions
•Residents should check the online calendar and provide input
Mayor Dan Butterman highlighted a recent "Wall That Heals" visit that drew hundreds, said 30 petitioners raised concerns about a recent hills arts festival at a council meeting, and announced the resignation of 2nd Ward council member Cecilia Walsh Russo, asking residents to submit letters of interest.
Discussion Points
•30 petitioners raised concerns about a recent hills arts festival, referred to in the transcript as 'Kano's festival'.
•Mayor framed the remarks as beginning a larger conversation about how to support arts while addressing concerns.
•Mayor highlighted community turnout and volunteer involvement for the exhibit.
•Mayor requested letters of interest from 2nd Ward residents.
•Resignation announced and reason (accepted state job) provided.
Directions
•City will solicit letters of interest and review them for appointment.
Public comment dominated the Oct. 6 Oneonta Common Council meeting as dozens of residents debated whether drag and burlesque performances at the City of the Hills festival were appropriate for a family-friendly downtown event; council later discussed budget guidance, parking permits, airport funding and water/sewer rates.
Discussion Points
•Accessibility concerns and prioritization (workers, residents, handicapped).
•Allegations that a performer at City of the Hills engaged in indecent exposure in a public, family-advertised festival.
•Audit reports presented as unmodified with no single-audit findings.
•Claims of increased homelessness locally and links to rent inflation.
•Concerns about enforcement costs and effect on turnover for downtown businesses.
•Council asked about extension for airport management and fee structure.
•Defenses of drag as artistic expression and warnings about discriminatory targeting of LGBTQ+ community.
•Examples presented that jurisdictions with good-cause laws did not see housing supply shrink, per speaker's claims.
•Options discussed: stay within tax cap initially; consider occupancy tax and sales-tax baseline increases; use of restricted reserves.
•Pilot permit concept: limited number of permits, designated lots, not guaranteed spot but permit-holders allowed to exceed time limit.
•Projected 23.3% health-insurance premium increase and its potential $900K budget impact.
•Reports of death threats, doxxing and online harassment of performers.
•Requests to review ordinances and enforcement practices to distinguish protected speech from unlawful harassment.
•Requests to staff and the council to consider event guidelines or venue restrictions for explicit performances.
•Short discussion clarifying project expectations and timeline.
•Staff projection of sales-tax revenue and occupancy tax; recommendation to budget conservatively.
•Warrants and consent agenda approved by roll call.
Decisions
•Amendment approved by roll call; no other airport funding decisions made at meeting.
•Auditor reports accepted; warrants approved as recorded.
•Council provided working guidance: sales-tax baseline approx. $6.6M, occupancy-tax estimate $400K, keep unappropriated fund-balance allocation near prior year ($1.8M) for draft development. No final levy decision at this meeting.
•No final vote on a permit pilot at Oct. 6 meeting; guidance given to staff.
•No formal adoption of event guidance or policy at this meeting.
•No immediate policy change or enforcement action recorded at the meeting.
•No ordinance vote or formal referral recorded at the Oct. 6 meeting.
Directions
•Administration to incorporate $25,000 amendment into capital project tracking and budget documents; report back in future budget meetings.
•Administration to provide audit materials to council for budget planning.
•Council to continue reviewing the cause-eviction proposal; staff to supply data and options in future meetings.
•Finance to proceed with warrants payment and continue budget reporting.
•No ordinance proposed or voted on at the meeting; council left matter for further study.
•Staff asked to review enforcement practices and report back to council; mayor offered office hours for constituent follow-up.
•Staff to design a limited pilot with number of permits, lot assignments, enforcement approach and evaluation timeline; bring back to council for approval.
•Staff to meet with petitioners and event organizers; Mayor offered office hours for follow-up.
•Staff to produce draft budget under tax-cap baseline, plus alternative scenarios showing levy increases and fund-balance use.
•Staff to supply prioritized lists of department requests and a list of cuts made in prior rounds for council reconsideration.
The Oneonta Planning Commission reviewed an application for a garage at 61 East Street, heard two recorded audio statements from the absent applicant, found drainage plans and impervious-surface information lacking, voted to deny the application, and advised the applicant may reapply with drainage details and plans.
Discussion Points
•Applicant requested redaction of name and address from online materials
•Applicant's recorded statement requested redaction of name/address from online records
•Commissioners expressed concern the submitted drawings did not show garage drainage or where the French drain discharged
•Commissioners noted that denial will remove the application from future agendas until resubmitted
•Commissioner stated planning applications are public record and cannot simply be redacted by the commission
•Estimate that impervious coverage exceeds 30% threshold
•Need for map showing French drain discharge
•Requirement for specific garage drainage plans and contractor drawings
•Staff/agency estimated the property likely exceeds the 30% impervious-coverage threshold
Decisions
•Motion to deny application at 61 East Street passed
Directions
•Applicant advised to reapply with the requested materials
•Applicant may reapply; denial will remove item from future agendas
•Staff to request drainage map and contractor drawings if the applicant reapplies
Community, Legislation, Infrastructure, and Public Safety - September 22, 2026
The Oneonta Public Safety Committee met on Sept. 22 to review minutes, request local eviction and rent data before considering a good-cause eviction ordinance, discuss yard-waste collection options (including possible centralized drop-offs, seasonal crews and a TANF-funded pilot), consider e-bike rules and safety, and move to a closed-door session to discuss personnel.
Discussion Points
•Chair moved to enter closed-door session to discuss personnel and invited certain council members to remain.
•Chair requested eviction counts and rent-increase data for Oneonta.
•Classification of e-bikes and alignment with bicycle rules should be explored.
•Education and helmet distribution preferred over immediate ticketing by some participants.
•Item was deferred pending staff report; no formal decision recorded.
•Options discussed: scheduled central collection, weekend drop-off sites, seasonal/youth crews, possible TANF grant funding.
•Residents reported bag durability issues and access problems.
•Safety concerns: sidewalk riding and pedestrian conflicts.
Decisions
•Motion seconded; transcript ends before formal vote recorded.
Directions
•City clerk and city administrator asked to gather eviction and rent data.
•Item carried to next meeting to include absent participants.
•Non-sitting participants to be dismissed; three council members to remain in room.
•Staff to ask police chief for materials and to consult local bike vendor Sam Baskin.
•Staff to prepare cost, liability and program estimates for inclusion in the 2027 budget discussion.
Finance, Administration and Strategic Operations - October 1, 2026
Oneonta City Council finance and operations items reviewed: two appointments were proposed for local boards, budget reviews including a $1,000,000 airport capital project with a $900,000 state grant, a $14,000 operating adjustment for road salt, splash pad procurement and schedule, an intermunicipal equipment-sharing discussion with the county, and a quarterly staffing report. Council directed several items to the consent agenda and asked staff for follow-ups.
Discussion Points
•Candidate noted as lifelong Oneonta resident with ~30 years real estate experience.
•Choice between general fund contingency and unrestricted fund balance discussed.
•City borrowed 30 tons from the state earlier and must return it.
•Council asked about overtime/pay/insurance and whether the city would maintain equipment.
•Council noted the departure of the water treatment plant chief operator and competitive hiring environment.
•Council praised nominee’s aviation experience and pilot background.
•County equipment loaned per incident; reimbursement mechanism exists.
•Demolition must be completed by end of next week for vendor to install on the 12th.
•Manufacturer representative said delivery arrangement was the manufacturer's responsibility.
Oneonta Common Council discussed a contested $1,000,000 state grant advance and possible recovery plan, awarded contracts for a comprehensive plan and Brownfield Opportunity Area, considered a change to a deputy purchasing stipend, and debated public-safety and transparency issues for license-plate readers and e-bikes.
Discussion Points
•Access requires badge number and case number; ICE is not an authorized recipient.
•Council proposed public communication to clarify capabilities and safeguards.
•E-bikes increasingly resemble motorized vehicles without clear classification; helmet use and lighting/reflector issues pose safety risks.
•Enforcement complexity: determining whether city, county or state rules apply; retailers' labeling and buyer education are part of the solution.
•Organizational restructuring and facility needs linked to planned projects.
•Questions about union (CSEA) implications and whether the stipend is budgeted.
•Rationale for increasing stipend from $1,000 to $2,500 tied to defining duties and modernizing procurement processes.
•Scope: citywide comprehensive plan update with several small-area plans; BOA outreach focused near the Depot industrial-commercial area.
•Scope of sewer replacement on Union Street (alignment and lateral replacement).
•Shue alleged the city advanced $1,000,000 from the general fund in Dec 2023 to cover Massey Field work and has not been reimbursed by the state.
•Shue requested the city obtain the full state file (correspondence, applications, agreements, reimbursement submissions, cancellation/denial notices) and adopt a recovery plan.
•State grant amounts: $135,000 (comp plan) and ~$297,000 (BOA) with local matches of ~$15,000 and ~$33,000 respectively.
•System is in-house, not cloud-based, and does not use AI.
Decisions
•No formal council vote recorded; staff asked to follow up.
Directions
•Administrator to return with scheduling/timeline ahead of budget cycle.
•City Administrator to work with finance to request the state file and report to council on avenues for recovery.
•City attorney to review contracts; planning staff to form a steering committee and begin public outreach.
•Finance staff to provide written duty scope and confirm labor/union procedure before formal appointment vote.
•Police department to provide recommendations; clips/transportation committee to consider ordinance updates and education campaigns.
•Staff to prepare a media explainer and recommend policy changes for data access and retention.
Landmarks and Historic Preservation Commission - September 14, 2026
The Oneonta Landmarks and Historic Preservation Commission met in September to review multiple certificate of appropriateness applications, approving several porch and screening projects while tabling or separating fence proposals for further review; members also discussed outreach for a barn tax credit workshop and homeowner notification about historic-district status.
Discussion Points
•Applicant described ramp/porch materials and dimensions and need for safe entry; commissioners asked about wood species and PVC risers.
•Application originally submitted incorrectly; corrected materials to be provided; applicant must attend per policy.
•Directions to contact county and community development, and prepare communications materials.
•Porch steps to be renewed with hardwood treads; PVC suggested for risers; fence to protect community garden and privacy for SOAR studio participants.
•Promoting barn tax-credit workshop via press release, community calendar, and targeted outreach to property owners; checking survey/archives for barn listings; improving notifications on property transfer to flag historic status.
•Removal of a 3,500,000 BTU boiler and replacement with large heat-pump condensers; railing design to meet spindle spacing and top rail height code.
•Screening fence to hide dumpsters and parking; wood and stain preferred over chain link; city lease requires Logan's install and maintain.
Decisions
•Application approved as presented; supplemental materials accepted.
•Proceed with outreach planning; follow up at subsequent meetings.
•Type II action declared; application accepted.
•Type II action declared; application approved; Chair abstained due to conflict.
Directions
•Add photos and diagrams to record; Logan's to coordinate installation.
•Commission staff to coordinate with community development and prepare press release and community-calendar entries; check archival survey for barn addresses.
•Fence application to be submitted separately with street elevations and detailed picket style.
•Resubmit fence-specific documentation and attend meeting.
Presenter reviewed 2024 comptroller data comparing Oneonta spending and revenue categories to peer cities, highlighted data gaps and suggested focused peer comparisons; council members discussed transportation, utilities, tax-exempt parcels, and budget projections including reserves and health-insurance cost increases.
Discussion Points
•$48,000,000 of exempt assessed value is under PILOTs and may convert to taxable status.
•Committee members recommended narrowing peer cities to improve meaningful comparisons.
•Exempt parcels are ~6.43% of parcels but account for ~47% of exempt assessed value.
•Health-insurance cost estimate increased from ~14% to ~17%.
•If expenses are fully expended, restricted reserves of about $1,600,000 could be used.
•Narrow comparisons to a few similar municipalities for meaningful results.
•Oneonta’s sanitation reporting is mainly sewer, while other cities may include refuse and garbage.
•Presenters reported $8.6M (highways) and $2.5M (bus service) for 2024.
•Presenter to reuse prior survey form and contact peer cities.
•Presenter warned that comptroller reporting varies and can hinder direct comparisons.
•Transportation totals include both operating and capital expenses, which can inflate single-year figures if a capital project occurred.
•Utilities costs are allocated across multiple funds, not a single utilities line.
Directions
•Agency official to provide detailed, line-by-line projections for 2027 salary and fringe costs.
•Councilors to email suggested peer cities; presenter to start outreach and report back with a proposed list.
•Flag fund-level allocation differences in future peer comparisons.
•Presenter to follow up with selected peer municipalities and reuse prior survey form to request detailed budget breakouts.
•Staff to provide detail on PILOT terms and include potential taxable conversions in revenue scenarios.
•When comparing peers, flag and separate capital projects from recurring operating costs.